A quiet Old Town–style courtyard with cane bistro chairs, a pale stone table, aged brick paving and tropical greenery in winter sunshine.

What's New at Old Town's Best-Known Addresses This Winter

November 19, 2026

Old Town's food and drink scene will look different this season, but very few of the changes are brand-new buildings. A former bank on Southard Street now has four kitchens and a speakeasy behind its original vault door. The Duval Street mansion that housed the Hard Rock Cafe for 30 years now has a Key West saloon in it, and that saloon brought its own crew and some of Hard Rock's. Schooner Wharf Bar is set to get new owners after four decades, and the bar's best-known yearly events are written into the lease the buyers would take over.

In most of these cases the address, the building and many of the people stay put while the business changes. Here's what has changed at each one going into winter.

The Reserve Kept the Bank on Southard Street

For eight years the former Bank of America branch at 510 Southard Street sat empty. The building's history goes back further than that: KeysNews reported that the First Federal Savings & Loan Association once stood at this location, and that the new business would keep much of the building's 1962 architecture and art.

J.C. and Patty Pernas own The Reserve. Construction started in October 2025, and the building is about 5,000 square feet. The kitchens went into what used to be the bank's office rooms, which were rebuilt to open up the space. The speakeasy uses the steel vault door from the bank. J.C. Pernas told KeysNews that one of the bars rotates, an idea he took from the revolving bar at New Orleans' Hotel Monteleone, and he called it "the southernmost rotating bar in the United States of America."

The Reserve's website lists four independent kitchens. Cassaforte has pizza, pasta and panini, Coquina is seafood, ¡Salud! is Spanish tapas, and the fourth is Salty Chef. The three bars are the Exchange, the Ledger and the Vault, all named after the building's banking past. The venue is in its soft opening, with Mondays closed for now, and the site still shows menus as coming soon. Pernas told KeysNews the plan was for all four kitchens to be run by restaurants already operating in Key West. The place would be open seven days a week, roughly noon to 11 p.m., and the whole space could be rented for private events.

After eight dark years, the Southard Street corner has its lights on again, and now it has a stage.

313 Duval Is Still a Music Address, Now Run Locally

The Hard Rock Cafe closed at 313 Duval Street in April 2026, ending a 30-year run. Linda Turek bought the property in May. Smokin' Tuna Saloon then moved from its Charles Street location into the mansion and held its soft opening on Thursday, Sept. 3, at 11 a.m., according to KeysNews.

Some of the staff came along with the building. KeysNews reported that Kim Sewell, who had been Hard Rock's general manager, became general manager at Smokin' Tuna, and that the saloon expected to hire former Hard Rock employees. When the Hard Rock closed, the change looked like a chain leaving Duval. On the ground floor, it was a familiar Key West operation stepping in with several of the same people.

The food and the music are where you'll see the difference. Smokin' Tuna's own site promotes seafood baskets, conch fritters, smoked-tuna dip and live music, with no cover charge. The Florida Keys tourism council's October 16 release described the saloon as known for affordable food and local musicians. The 300 block of Duval has had live music for decades, and it still does. The bands are just more likely to be local now.

135 Duval Is Lined Up for a Brewery

The one name on this list that's new to Key West is two blocks closer to the water. Beer Church Brewing Co. plans to open its first Florida location at 135 Duval Street, at the corner of Greene, in the former RockHouse Live space across from Sloppy Joe's. KeysNews reported that owners John Lustina and Jane Simon expect to open in December. WhatNow's October 1 report puts the target at winter 2026.

The plan includes beer brewed on site, wood-fired Neapolitan pizza, fish and shrimp dishes, all-day breakfast and brunch, and rooftop seating. The stated hours are 8 a.m. to 2 a.m. every day. Hardly anything at that end of Duval serves an 8 a.m. breakfast and is still open at last call. On a Sunday morning, residents near Greene Street could have a new place for brunch within a short walk.

711 Duval Has Its Founder Back

AQUA closed at 711 Duval Street effective Monday, July 6. The Aquanettes had played their last show on the home stage the night before, Keys Weekly reported. Since then the club has gone back to the person who started it. Founder Jill McDonald returned with partner Sandy Thomas to take it on, and Keys Weekly's October 15 story said a roof replacement had to happen before the club could reopen.

Of all the changes on this list, AQUA's is the clearest example of an old name and its founder coming back to the same address. For the 700 block of Duval, the work happening now is about bringing back a club people already know.

Schooner Wharf Is Changing Hands, and Its Events Stay in the Lease

Of all these addresses, the Historic Seaport bar has the deepest roots. Paul and Evalena Worthington started Schooner Wharf Bar in 1986 aboard the brigantine Diamante, two years after they came to Key West. The business later moved onto land at Key West Bight. The city owns the property, so a sale of the bar goes through public boards.

KeysNews reported that on Wednesday, Oct. 14, the Key West Bight Management District Board voted unanimously to recommend transferring the lease to Tidal Shift Ventures LLC. Jeff Sorg and Mike Croce formed that company, and they are the managing partners of the Green Parrot Bar and Half Shell Raw Bar. Final approval belongs to the Caroline Street Corridor and Bahama Village Community Redevelopment Agency, which put the lease assignment on its Nov. 5 agenda.

Under the proposal, the buyers would take over the existing lease as it stands. The bar keeps the Schooner Wharf Bar name, and the terms of its recently renewed 10-year lease don't change. That lease runs from Oct. 1, 2026, through Sept. 30, 2036. It sets annual base rent at $454,396.94, adjusted each year with the Consumer Price Index, and covers about 9,917 square feet indoors and out, with 205 licensed seats and live entertainment.

The lease also includes provisions for continuing the Minimal Regatta, the Open Air Art and Music Fair and the Lighted Boat Parade. The Bight Board said Schooner Wharf has hosted about 30 events a year, including the Battle of the Bars and the Wreckers' Cup races. Capt. Kelly George, who told the board he knows both parties, called the sale "a win/win for both parties."

Of everything on this list, this matters most to people who live in Old Town. The Lighted Boat Parade is a December tradition at the Bight. Its connection to Schooner Wharf is part of the lease, so it doesn't depend on who owns the bar. And the buyers already run two bars that Old Town residents know well.

If you want more on how the neighborhood's blocks each run on their own schedule, our posts on Fleming Street's monthly rhythm and Fantasy Fest's closure calendar are good next reads.

At Bascom Grooms Real Estate, we've been an independent Key West brokerage since 1999, and we're always glad to talk about which block fits the way you live, from the Bight to the Southard Street bank. Whenever you're ready, contact us, or browse our Old Town neighborhood page.

Work With Us

Whether you are thinking of buying, selling, or investing in Florida Keys real estate, you can count on the experts at Bascom Grooms Real Estate. Contact us today to discuss all your real estate needs!